Oil and gas development might be at stake in the land use debate surrounding a code change to the zoning for two Kenai neighborhoods. 052711 NEWS 1 Peninsula Clarion Oil and gas development might be at stake in the land use debate surrounding a code change to the zoning for two Kenai neighborhoods.
Friday, May 27, 2011

Story last updated at 5/27/2011 - 1:23 pm

Zoning changes might shake up oil, gas works

Oil and gas development might be at stake in the land use debate surrounding a code change to the zoning for two Kenai neighborhoods.

Among the parties working through the allowable land uses in two Kenai neighborhoods is the Alaska Mental Health Trust, which owns land in MAPS and subsurface rights in Three Ws.

Currently, both subsurface and surface extraction of natural resources is allowed with a conditional use permit in neighborhoods zoned as Rural Residential 1.

But the changes proposed by residents of the two neighborhoods where that zone is in place would disallow both of those uses.

For the Alaska Mental Health Trust that is the major point of contention.

"That took our entire bundle of rights in respect to Three Ws," said Greg Jones, the executive director for the Mental Health Trust Land Office.

The state and federal government own most of the subsurface rights in Alaska. Landowners do not. But the Alaska Mental Health Trust does. And Three Ws falls right into one of its subsurface parcels.

The trust owns land and subsurface rights throughout the state. It is charged with using its property to generate revenue that supports Alaskans' mental well-being. On the Kenai Peninsula, the trust owns thousands of acres of subsurface rights, meaning they benefit from oil and gas development in the area.

The trust provides funding for a variety of local organizations.

According to a report provided by the trust, it has spent about $777,528 on the Kenai Peninsula over the last seven years. That money has been leveraged to receive another $3 million. The funding has benefited Serenity House at the Central Peninsula Hospital, programs offered by Bridges Community Resources, the Kenai Peninsula Food Bank, and other entities.

But a prohibition on development could limit the trusts' ability to generate revenue for Alaskans and limit oil and gas development in the city.

Jones said the trust usually holds lease sales when industry interest warrants. None is scheduled for the Three Ws neighborhood, but it doesn't take long for them to come together, he said.

"We could easily do one in the next year," he said.

But the code change would make the leases useless, because the subsurface deposits couldn't be accessed.

Jones said a body of law supports the notion that the city can't take away those rights entirely, and he didn't think that piece of the changes would hold up in court. But, he said, he didn't want to see the court get involved.

"It should be a cooperative process," Jones said.

Jones said he understood why neighbors wouldn't want drill rigs in their back yards.

"The surface is, that's your neighborhood," he said.

But Jones said there's another option: drilling sideways.

"They've been doing it out of Kenai for 40 years," he said.

And Jones said the neighbors would likely be involved if drilling was going to impact their lives. Because a conditional use permit is currently required for subsurface development in the RR1 zone, the city and residents would have the opportunity to see any plans before they were enacted.

Among the trust's parcels is the land near Walmart where Buccaneer Alaska is drilling. Jones said the trust owns the subsurface rights, but not the land. Before drilling, Buccaneer had to negotiate with both the trust, and the landowner. The trust's permission alone didn't greenlight that project, he said.

Buccaneer is currently working through the conditional use permitting process for other Mental Health Trust land in Kenai. The proposed project would drill one or more wells near Highbush Lane off the Kenai Spur Highway later this summer, if all goes according to plan.

The trust has another interest in the land use changes. It owns nearly five acres along the Kenai Spur Highway in MAPS, which Jones said is the largest undeveloped parcel in the neighborhood.

He said the trust wanted to be part of the discussion on other land use changes, too, but doubted that the work could be done by the August deadline that Kenai's city council set at their last meeting.

"It's hard to put something like this together that quickly," Jones said.

Molly Dischner can be reached at



If you think the Kenai Peninsula is beautiful in the summer, you should see it when cloaked under a thick blanket of white with the aurora borealis rippling through the celestial canopy above.


Whether intentionally seeking berries for jellies and jams or just out for a casual hike, residents and visitors will find the 50-some varieties of wild berries in Alaska hard to resist.


There’s adventure and beauty in the wild country, but also an element of risk.

2010 Peninsula Clarion award winners

Best Education Reporting
1st Place – Dante Petri, “All under one roof

Suzan Nightingale Award: Best Columnist

2nd Place – Will Morrow, “Voices of the Clarion”

Best Sustained Coverage

3rd Place – Dante Petri, “Mt. Redoubt Eruption”

Best News Photo

3rd Place – M. Scott Moon, “Bear Rescue

Best Photo Portrait
3rd Place – M. Scott Moon, “Ear Gauger

Best Audio Slideshow
2nd Place – M. Scott Moon, “Learning to ski

Best Use of Story and Photos by a Journalist
2nd Place – Joseph Robertia, “Dipnet disaster averted

More headlines

AP US & World

Updated 7:09 AM ET
Romney: 'Barack Obama has failed America'
Mass. towns digging out after tornadoes kill 4
AP sources: US-Pakistan form an anti-terror squad
NY rep says he didn't send Twitter photo
SD governor urges evacuations as flooding looms
WHO: E. coli outbreak caused by new strain
Job gains help states narrow budget gaps
Just one flight: Impending loss in shuttle family
Japan's PM beats censure, hints at resignation
More News